Facebook Places: Who Opened Pandora’s Box?

Facebook logo

All of us here at AndyBarlowBlog.com want you to be informed (yeah, because it takes a staff to run this blog), and as much as is possible, we want to provide good, solid information to you as a web user. It’s also a good thing to dispel rumors and bust myths whenever one rears it’s ugly head. So here’s the myth we’re bustin’ today:

Facebook launched Facebook Places this week. Anyone can find out where you are when you are logged in. It gives the actual address & map location of where you are as you use Facebook. Make sure your children know about this! To undo: go to “Account”, “Account Settings”, “Notifications”, then scroll down to “Places” & uncheck the 2 boxes. Make sure to save changes & re-post this!

I first saw this as a friend’s status on Friday, August 27th, but I paid it no attention since it was only from 1 friend. Now I’ve seen it 10+ times since the 1st sighting, so after spending some time debunking it this evening on Facebook, I decided a more public forum might be appropriate. I’m going to break down this “cut & paste” status piece by piece, showing it’s falsehoods as such & reinforcing the little truth that it does actually convey.

1. “Facebook launched Facebook Places this week.
Places actually launched on August 19th (article). If you’re posting this as your status, you’re late and already off to a bad start.

2. “Anyone can find out where you are when you are logged in.
Aaah, wrong. Here’s how places works, generally speaking.

a. Places works only on mobile devices (smart phones like the iPhone) running the Facebook Mobile app. If you only use FB on a computer, you cannot (at this time) use the Places feature, hereby making it impossible for Places to “track” you.

b. Places is a geo-caching type of feature that allows users to “check in” at a place – their favorite restaurant, shopping center, friend’s house, etc. The user must initate a tag in Places – it does not operate on it’s own. In other words, you have to check in – Places does not check you in.

3. “It gives the actual address & map location of where you are as you use Facebook.
This is true, but only partially true. Places shows a pin drop on a map using your mobile phones “current location” GPS feature. Once you tell Places to check in, Facebook checks your friends list to see if anyone else has checked in anywhere around you. You’ll then see a map with other pins, but only for friends who have checked in using Places. Yesterday as my wife and I sat in Freebirds World Burrito in Corpus Christi, TX, she checked in using Places. I then checked in about 10 minutes later and was at that time greeted with a message saying “(Friend’s Name) is also at Freebirds.”

4. “Make sure your children know about this!
Pu – lease. This doesn’t even warrant a comment. Why would they care? They would probably think it’s cool anyway…don’t bother.

5. “To undo: go to “Account”, “Account Settings”, “Notifications”, then scroll down to “Places” & uncheck the 2 boxes.
The key word here is NOTIFICATIONS. When you uncheck these 2 boxes, Facebook will no longer notify you via email, at the email address with which you signed up, that someone tagged you using Places or checked you in. That’s all that changes when you uncheck the 2 boxes. Unchecking these 2 boxes does nothing to diminish the functionality of Places, even on your mobile phone. It’ll just keep your email inbox a bit cleaner.

6. “Make sure to save changes & re-post this!
PLEASE, in the name of the patron Saint Snopes, do not repost this! Instead, post this link that will bring people here so they can get a full explanation of how Places works – (copy & paste) http://ow.ly/2x7KF.

Now see, that didn’t hurt a bit, did it? Let’s keep the social networks a sane & informed place!

  • May

    You’ve provided incomplete information.

    While yes, the thing going around is about the notifications, it misses the PRIVACY issue.

    A user can turn off the notifications but should instead pre-preemptively go to their privacy settings > Custom > Things I share/Things others share and turn off if others can tag them at places.

    The issue here isn’t about me sharing with my friends (and let’s face it, the term “Friend” has been massively re-defined by FB to mean “someone I met at a party three years ago who says he knows my sister” instead of “person I like spending time with”) but instead about others sharing information about me without my permission. Do I really want that guy I met at a party three years ago know that I’m at PubXYZ with a mutual friend – probably not. Do I want my overly-friendly co-worker to know that I’m downstairs from my office getting a coffee with overly-friendly coworker #2? Nope. ~I~ should be able to decide the information I share about me; not someone else.

    Basically, while you’ve provided some information, you’ve missed the mark in informing those who are concerned about their privacy about how to manage this new feature. Patting your readers on the head and telling them to be informed…. should mean informing them.

    • http://andybarlowblog.com Andy

      Aah, the open letter. I read about these today (SCL – Writing Open Letters), but I never in my wildest dreams dreamt I’d be the recipient of one! In this case, it’s a blog reply, only leaving a negative comment without the possibility of furthering discussion.

      To May: here’s my short reply…
      1. The status in question did nothing to point people to their privacy settings, and the point of the blog post wasn’t to inform Facebook users of such. It was, as stated, to debunk the myth stated specifically in the status making circles on profiles. I wasn’t aiming at the mark of “informing those who are concerned about their privacy…”, so is that a miss?

      2. The default privacy settings for Places, concerning both who sees your check ins and who can check you in, is for “friends” only. If a user is concerned about their privacy, they should certainly check those settings and manage them accordingly. Which leads me to…

      3. While I’d tend to agree with you that the word friend has been redefined in social media, I would disagree that Facebook is responsible. If you don’t want to be friends with that guy you met at a party 3 years ago, then don’t. It’s still up to the end user, and no one is forcing you to maintain old or loose social connections.

      Thanks for leaving a comment May.

  • Karla

    Thank you so very much!!! Finally someone who is willing to investigate before launching into a unsubstantiated attack. It is best to always speak the truth.